From “rosy” bulletins to transparency
Church historian Alberto Melloni recalled an anecdote from John Paul II’s papacy. The 84-year-old pope was hospitalized at Gemelli with an acute respiratory infection and underwent a tracheotomy to help him breathe, yet the next morning his spokesman gave an implausibly upbeat update about his regular breakfast. According to Melloni, telling untruths about the pope was then simply the rule of the game.
Twenty years later, Leo XIV has changed those rules. His personal physician, Dr. Luigi Carbone, and Gemelli’s head of thoracic surgery, Dr. Stefano Margaritora, sign the daily medical bulletins, while the Vatican spokesman mainly provides non-medical details such as the Mass he celebrated or the officials who visited. The updates are spare but authoritative, reflecting a degree of transparency long unusual at the Vatican.
American-style governance
According to Julie Rubio, a professor of Christian social ethics at the Jesuit School of Theology of Santa Clara University, the pope’s handling of his illness is textbook American corporate good governance applied to the Church: relying on experts, transparency and evaluation. She said:
Those kinds of practices actually can be pretty transformative to a place.














