When the alternative is also at risk
The Good Fish Guide uses a familiar traffic-light system: green is the best choice, amber means think twice, and red means avoid. In this update, the most significant changes concern popular white fish:
European hake caught in the North Sea, Celtic Seas and Bay of Biscay has been downgraded from green to amber because of growing fishing pressure and declining stocks.
Coley landed in key UK fishing areas has been rated red because of falling populations and the absence of recovery plans.
North-east Arctic coley has also been downgraded, while Icelandic coley keeps its green rating.
For many British households, coley is an affordable choice and hake a candidate to replace cod. The fact that both have been downgraded shows how pressure shifts from one species to the next when consumers switch but management fails to keep up.
Haddock: two different fates
Icelandic haddock, an important supply for fish and chips, has dropped from green to amber after catches exceeded scientific advice. It is a warning that even fisheries once regarded as models can slip if discipline is relaxed.

















