MAIN STORY
The court examined authority, not the abolition of investment risk
According to Reuters and legal publication Bar & Bench, the Supreme Court on October 15 declined to overturn the Bombay High Court’s 2023 decision that quashed the write-off of approximately 8,415 crore rupees in AT1 bonds. The central point was whether the bank administrator had lawful authority to extinguish the instruments under the government’s final reconstruction scheme.
The timing proved pivotal. An earlier draft contained an explicit provision wiping out the AT1 bonds, but that language was omitted from the final plan announced on March 13, 2020. On March 14, the administrator notified exchanges of the write-off. The case thus turned not simply on whether such bonds could absorb losses, but on who could order it, when and pursuant to which legal powers.
How a bank rescue became a six-year dispute
AT1 bonds are bank capital instruments that generally pay higher returns than conventional debt while exposing holders to significant loss. Subject to specified conditions, they can be written down or converted to shares when a bank reaches a point of non-viability. They are not equivalent to insured deposits.
















