MAIN CONTENT
A rescue mechanism meets a legal boundary
The RBI's November 13 review petition, described in Reuters reporting on November 18, challenges the practical consequences of the Supreme Court's October 15 judgment. The judgment upheld an earlier Bombay High Court decision setting aside the write-down of Yes Bank's AT1 instruments. A judicial finding that the 2020 decision lacked the requisite authority does not necessarily mean the underlying bonds were risk-free; rather, it raises questions about the lawful route for imposing losses.
AT1 securities are designed to provide a capital buffer. They offer potentially higher returns precisely because investors may lose their investment when a bank reaches a defined point of distress. Yet the contractual risk of loss and the regulator's power to impose that loss are distinct questions. This is the seam that the present litigation exposes.
Why the central bank fears a precedent
According to the filing reviewed by Reuters, the RBI argues that leaving the AT1 claims intact after restructuring would defeat their intended function under India's Basel III framework. It says restoring the liabilities could reduce the capital benefit created by the rescue investments and weaken protection for existing depositors. Those are the regulator's arguments, not an independent finding by the court.

















