A clause buried in the bill
The bill gives all future governments the power to order “certain complex or lengthy cases to be tried without a jury” in England and Wales, except in homicide or rape cases. At present, judge-only trials in the crown court are planned only for complicated financial fraud cases.
What worries lawyers is the possibility of adding further offences without a new vote in parliament. It is the first time such a power has been proposed, coming just after the government retreated in the face of opposition to its plan to restrict jury trials.
Fears of “a stroke of a pen”
Flora Page KC, who represented victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal at the public inquiry, said removing juries in serious fraud cases was troubling enough, but the power to extend it without parliamentary scrutiny was even more so.
*“Any serious or complex case could, by a stroke of a pen… become another judge-only trial.” — Flora Page*
She sketched a scenario: if officials or ministers were charged by police, the government could quickly pass a statutory instrument making it a judge-only trial, so that a political case would be heard without public scrutiny and without members of the public deciding guilt.

















