St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy
The plaintiffs, two Catholic parishes, two parents and the Archdiocese of Denver, argue they are denied public funds "solely on account of their religious exercise." The case is a new test of the relationship between First Amendment religious freedom and state nondiscrimination rules.
Colorado's preschool program
Key points of the program and the dispute:
- Launched in 2023, the program pays for 15 hours of preschool a week, about $6,300 a year per child.
- Providers must meet "equal-opportunity requirements," including enrollment without regard to religious affiliation, gender identity or sexual orientation.
- The Catholic schools ask parents to sign a statement on "Community Beliefs and Commitments" and to refrain from publicly undermining the church; Colorado denied them an exemption.
The Catholic schools' arguments
The schools argue it is enough to apply the logic of Carson v. Makin (2022), in which the Supreme Court rebuked Maine for excluding religious schools from a state tuition program. They also cite Trinity Lutheran (2017) and Espinoza (2020).

















