A ruling on procedure
Judge Myong Joun, an appointee of former President Joe Biden, agreed with Harvard that the Justice Department went to court before completing the mandatory steps aimed at persuading the university to provide applicant-level data voluntarily. In his view, the complaint did not show that the government had told Harvard what legal consequences would follow if it failed to comply, nor did it identify the specific violation.
He also stressed that the ruling does not settle whether the Justice Department and the Education Department can ultimately demand data on thousands of high school students who applied to Harvard. At a September hearing, he pressed government lawyers on their efforts to negotiate before suing and likened the administration's stance to an "ultimatum."
*"For example, the complaint does not allege that DOJ informed Harvard of the action it would take — namely, litigation — should Harvard fail to comply, nor does the complaint allege the specific failure identified." — Myong Joun*
The fight over admissions data
The investigation began in April 2025, when the Justice Department asked Harvard for five years of admissions data from its undergraduate college and its medical and law schools, including applicants' grades, standardized test scores, essays, extracurricular activities, admissions outcomes and race. The government said it needed the data to determine whether Harvard was complying with the Supreme Court's 2023 ruling ending race-conscious admissions, as well as Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

















