A 75-page inspection report
The August 6 "failure analysis" by Atlantic Coating Inspection, commissioned by contractor Atlantic Industrial Coatings (AIC), documented 85 points of failure with dozens of photos:
- The coating buckled along eight of the 10 expansion joints dividing the concrete slabs of the basin.
- Blisters appeared in nearly 40 places due to moisture or chemical fumes trapped beneath the liner.
- Peeling occurred in nearly two dozen spots, where layers separated from each other or from the basin.
- An additional 88 instances of damage were attributed to the Army Corps of Engineers during strength testing, 12 of which cut to the concrete.
The report makes no mention of vandalism, instead blaming improper materials and a rushed job. Its "lessons learned" boil down to two points: curing-time guidelines must be met, and coating products should be tested before they are applied.
Rushing for the 250th anniversary
Virginia-based AIC carried out the $14.7 million project under a no-bid contract awarded in the spring, with the Interior Department arguing that only a limited pool of contractors had the necessary qualifications and equipment. In April, Trump vowed to clean up the "filthy" water by resurfacing the more than 300,000-square-foot basin in what he called "American Flag Blue".
















