MAIN STORY
A proposal with immediate market consequences
MSCI’s statement dated October 15 in the United States landed in Asian markets on October 16. Its language marked a sharper turn than investors had anticipated. Rather than merely question whether Indonesia qualified as an emerging market, the index provider argued that a move to frontier-market status might not adequately capture the seriousness of the concerns reported by its institutional clients. It therefore proposed a standalone classification, beyond its mainstream emerging- and frontier-market products.
The market response was swift. Reuters reported an early drop of about 10% in Jakarta’s benchmark index, its lowest level in six years, while the rupiah lost around 0.6% and reached 18,000 per dollar. These are observations from the reporting window, not necessarily final closing levels. Investors worried that index-tracking funds could ultimately have to sell and that active managers might cut exposure well before a formal decision.
Indonesian shares had already lost more than 30% since the start of the year at the time of the original report, while overseas investors had sold a net $4.7 billion of equities. Those cumulative figures describe a broader deterioration and should not be attributed entirely to this announcement.














