A verdict that satisfied no one
On Thursday, judges at the Yogyakarta District Court declared Indahsari legally and convincingly guilty of child neglect, operating an educational facility without a licence and allowing violence against children to be carried out continuously, AFP reported. Along with five years in prison, she was ordered to pay a fine of 510 million rupiah, about £21,300; if she fails to pay, her property can be seized and auctioned.
The sentence was half the ten-year term requested by prosecutors. For a case that had provoked outrage across the world's fourth most populous country, many families had expected the court to send a much stronger signal.
“It is very unfair”
Parents who followed the hearing left the courtroom disappointed. Tri Susilawati urged prosecutors to challenge the ruling, saying the punishment did not match what had been done to the children.
Imedia Dwi Anjani, whose child was also among the victims, expressed similar frustration.
It is very unfair.
For these families, the harm is not abstract. Earlier this year, one father described how his three-year-old daughter cried hysterically each morning before daycare; he had assumed she simply wanted to stay home and play. Only after the scandal broke did parents begin to understand what their children's tears had been trying to tell them.
What police found in April
The investigation began on April 20, when a former caregiver, unable to bear what they had witnessed, reported the centre to local child protection officials and police. The raid that followed revealed conditions that stunned investigators:
- Toddlers aged roughly two to six with their hands and feet tied with strips of cloth.
- Up to 20 children kept together in a room measuring just three metres by three.
- Medical checks showing bruises on wrists and ankles consistent with being bound.
- A centre operating without a licence and, according to staff, without enough employees to care for the children.
Yogyakarta police chief Eva Guna Pandia said caregivers admitted tying some children to stop them disturbing the others. Little Aresha was sealed and shut down after the raid.
A wider web of responsibility
Indahsari is not the only person to face justice. In October, eleven caregivers who worked at Little Aresha were sentenced to between two and three years in prison and fined 60 million rupiah each, again well below the five years prosecutors had sought. Diyah Kusumastuti, chair of the foundation that ran the centre, faces separate proceedings, with prosecutors requesting ten years and accusing her of directing the abuse.
The scale of the case has grown steadily. Authorities first estimated that 53 of the 103 children enrolled had been abused; prosecutors now say they have identified 144 victims, and police have named 32 suspects in total. Each new figure has deepened the sense among parents that the system failed their children long before the courts were involved.
A national reckoning on childcare
The scandal has pushed authorities to act. Women's Empowerment and Child Protection Minister Arifah Fauzi met victims' families and promised stronger regulation, licensing and supervision of daycares nationwide. The governor of Yogyakarta ordered unlicensed centres to close, and parliamentary speaker Puan Maharani called for a stricter monitoring system.
We hope Yogyakarta will become the starting point for a national evaluation.
Another ministry has since opened a complaint and consultation service for daycares after further allegations, including one in Banda Aceh. Child protection advocates welcome these steps, but warn that rules on paper mean little without inspectors in the field and parents who know what warning signs to look for.















