Four defeats
No Supreme Court justice publicly dissented, and as is common in emergency cases, the court gave no reasoning. In September, the justices also rejected Trump's push to restrict mail voting nationwide, even though the court has sided with the administration in many other emergency appeals. California Attorney General Rob Bonta highlighted the administration's losing streak.
*"This latest decision should put an end to the Administration's attempt to disrupt California's elections through emergency court orders." — Rob Bonta*
A journey through the courts
The Justice Department sought to force California to hold the challenged ballots until voters' citizenship could be verified, but was turned down at every level:
- District court: Judge David O. Carter denied the request, warning that segregating ballots would wreak havoc on the election and erode trust in the democratic process.
- Appeals court: a three-judge panel upheld his order 2-1; the dissenting judge argued California's refusal to separate ballots encourages violation of federal law.
- Supreme Court: rejected the emergency request without even asking the other side to respond.















