MAIN STORY
A comparison nearly a century in the making
The argument did not begin in the twenty-first century. After the anti-Jewish Kristallnacht violence of 1938, anti-colonial intellectual C. L. R. James drew parallels between persecution of Jews in Europe and racial oppression in Africa. His point was not that every atrocity followed the same script. Rather, imperial power had already normalized practices through which some people were treated as less entitled to freedom, land and protection than others.
Nazi leaders themselves sometimes appealed to imperial precedents. Propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels compared Nazi detention camps with camps established by Britain during the Boer War, while Adolf Hitler imagined eastern European territory as a domain of German conquest. Such claims reveal how imperial examples circulated in Nazi thinking, but statements by perpetrators cannot establish a direct causal chain on their own. Historians must examine institutions, policy decisions and outcomes as well as rhetoric.
Objects that make an argument—and invite questions
Curated by historian Stephan Malinowski, Controversial Kinship uses material objects as starting points for difficult inquiry. Colonial-era equipment appears in dialogue with records of Nazi persecution and confinement.














