The mayor keeps his commissioner
On October 13, after days of questions, Mayor Zohran Mamdani confirmed he would not fire Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch. Pressure mounted after Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents shot an undocumented immigrant in the Bronx on October 8, and police clashed with protesters at the scene.
The next day, 17 far-left officials and candidates signed a letter calling for her to be replaced unless she undertook major police reforms. The shooting has no direct link to Israel or antisemitism, but the protests against Tisch predate it and carry deep implications for the city's roughly 1 million Jews.
An odd couple at City Hall
Tisch, a pro-Israel Jewish moderate from a billionaire family, has always made an odd couple with the socialist mayor who is critical of Israel. Not a police officer herself, she took the job nearly two years ago after a career in city government, earned praise as a competent manager under former mayor Eric Adams, and agreed to stay when Mamdani asked.
That decision reassured moderates, the business community and especially pro-Israel Jews, since she leads the force that often acts as first responder to antisemitic acts and polices anti-Israel protests.

















