MAIN CONTENT
A 9–8 quorum ruling hands Texas a victory as an employer
By a 9-to-8 vote, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals held that Congress violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause — which requires a majority of members in each chamber to be present to conduct official business — when it passed the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Lawmakers enacted the measure as part of a broader 1.7 trillion dollar spending bill during the peak of the Covid-19 pandemic after authorizing remote and proxy voting as a health precaution.
The ruling delivered a victory to outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who sued on behalf of Texas as an employer, arguing the statute exposed the state to administrative costs, investigations, and lawsuits from individuals and federal authorities. The decision immediately ends Texas's obligation as an employer to enforce the law and signals that other employers in the Fifth Circuit could expect to prevail against enforcement challenges.
"We conclude that the Act's passage was unconstitutional because the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum." Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals
















