An Investigation That Drew Attention
On Nov. 5, The New York Times published an investigation into the NewJeans contracts signed in 2022. The report raised concerns about early termination penalties, surveillance, the use of artists’ voices and likenesses, and how much the members and their families could influence the agreements. In a statement to local media, Hybe said the contracts complied with South Korean legal standards and were finalized after extensive negotiations.
Hybe’s Arguments
Hybe made several points to rebut the concerns:
- All Hybe labels sign the government-standard supplementary agreement for minors with their trainees, which remains in effect until they reach adulthood.
- Draft contracts were provided to the members and their families on Jan. 7, 2022; after nearly three months of written correspondence, proposed revisions and legal reviews, the contracts were signed in April. The Seoul High Court recognized that they took effect after sufficient discussion.
- The early termination penalty clause uses different wording from the government’s standard contract, but according to Hybe, its calculation yields the same financial outcome, based only on periods when the group generated revenue and excluding the pre-debut period.
- Use of voices and likenesses, including AI-generated content, requires individual consent; security cameras were installed only in common areas for safety; decisions on education were left to the artists and their families.















