MAIN ARTICLE
A private meeting and two understandings of its meaning
Vatican News reported that Leo met four men and three women who had experienced abuse in parishes, boarding schools, religious congregations or Church movements. The private Lourdes meeting lasted about two hours. According to the Holy See’s account, he listened to each person, including stories in which silence or complicity by those who might have helped deepened the harm. Participants brought proposals to prevent further abuse. This was not a public fact-finding hearing. Its first value was that people who had long carried the consequences could speak in their own voices to the institution’s leader.
Jérôme Guillement, one of the participants, subsequently told journalists that he understood the pope to recognize the systemic conditions that allowed perpetrators to flourish. On the return flight to Rome on 28 September, Leo said some participants had used the term “systemic abuse,” while he preferred to speak of organizations within the Church that had at times been abusive as a system. As Le Monde noted, that is narrower than a declaration about the entire Church everywhere. Reporting the survivors’ understanding and the pope’s public clarification side by side preserves the difference without treating either account as disposable.

















