MAIN CONTENT
Progress measured in paragraphs, not resolved disputes
At the 49th ASEAN Summit, Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said nearly 80 percent of the paragraphs in the proposed code of conduct had been provisionally agreed. The number reflects sustained diplomatic effort, but it is not a precise measure of the distance to a deal. One unresolved sentence about enforcement or geographical scope may matter more than dozens of settled procedural provisions.
Manila had hoped to finish the negotiations during its 2026 chairmanship. Passing the remaining task to Singapore, which chairs ASEAN in 2027, illustrates both the progress made and the limits of negotiating against a calendar. President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. said ASEAN and China would continue observing the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea while seeking a final code.
The Manila forum challenged expectations placed on ASEAN itself. The organization is a forum for consensus among states with divergent priorities, not a maritime tribunal empowered to award territory. Confusing those institutional functions can produce exaggerated optimism when talks move forward and equally exaggerated pessimism when they stall.















