MAIN CONTENT
When a link becomes a bill
The central disagreement is deceptively simple: is a link to a news article an act of distribution that deserves payment, or a signpost that sends an audience to the publisher? Agung Pamungkas, Google’s Indonesia government affairs and public policy manager, told lawmakers that mandatory payments for news links might constrain access to journalism. The company’s position highlights the role of search and discovery tools in directing readers toward independent websites.
Meta’s Indonesian public policy representative Berni Moestafa made a related but distinct case. A platform that faces a fee each time it displays a preview may decide to show fewer links, she argued, leaving news organisations with less referral traffic and fewer opportunities to convert readers into subscribers. This is a company argument, not an established estimate of the bill’s impact. The effects would depend on the final wording, licensing arrangements and platforms’ responses.
The unresolved question of human creativity
The proposal reaches beyond journalism. A draft reviewed by Reuters in July contemplated copyright protection for works produced with AI assistance when humans make a meaningful intellectual contribution, while excluding wholly machine-generated material.
















