A secret no longer
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal, a specialist court that oversees surveillance powers, ruled on Thursday that the government had not shown that revealing the existence of its notice to Apple would harm national security. Given how much had already entered the public domain, the tribunal said, confirmation would do little, if any, damage.
Until now, the government had said it could not comment because of a policy of neither confirming nor denying such security matters. Its lawyer argued that abandoning that stance would pose a national security risk and provide material assistance to hostile actors. The tribunal also issued private judgments that cannot be disclosed, and said later hearings would decide how far, if at all, the details of the notice can be revealed.
Privacy versus public safety
This technical capability notice simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so.
Responding to the ruling, the government said Apple had been helping police and intelligence agencies pursue criminals for several years in accordance with the law, and that the notice only obliges it to keep that ability.

















