A legal opinion that leans toward Brussels
According to Advocate General Kokott, the General Court imposed excessive requirements on the scope of its examination of the duration of the infringement and did not sufficiently link its conclusion to the assessment of the criteria that determine whether a company holds a dominant position. In other words, in her view, the lower court asked the Commission to prove more than was necessary.
An Advocate General's opinion is not binding, but the Court of Justice of the European Union usually follows the majority of such recommendations. That makes it a worrying signal for Google, which scored a rare victory over the Commission when the fine was scrapped in 2024. The case is C-826/24 P, Commission v Google and Alphabet (Google AdSense).
Three clauses and a decade of dominance
AdSense for Search is Google's intermediation service that lets websites such as online retailers and newspapers display search ads and share the revenue. The Commission said Google's contracts contained three types of clauses, covering exclusivity, ad placement and prior authorisation, that made it hard for competing services to get a foothold. The case was triggered by a complaint from Microsoft in 2010.

















