A sobering assessment
The report offers a frank account of what has been achieved since the US-mediated ceasefire took effect in October 2025. Although major fighting has stopped, the gap between commitments and reality remains wide.
“A ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely.” Board of Peace
The report stressed that the distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground remains the principal risk to the entire process.
Failures on both sides
The Board of Peace pointed to violations and inaction by both parties:
- Israel was criticised for an “absence of decisions” on training and deploying a Palestinian civilian police force to replace Hamas.
- Israeli restrictions on supplies and equipment, along with funding shortfalls, have hampered Gazans' ability to cope with seasonal flooding.
- Hamas was accused of taxing goods entering Gaza, affecting the availability of basic commodities, and of continuing attacks on Israeli troops.
According to the report, the commitment to cease all military activity has not been fully met by the parties. Since the ceasefire was struck, more than 1,600 Palestinians, many of them civilians, and five Israeli soldiers have been killed in Gaza.
A roadmap in deadlock
The wider plan, which calls for Hamas to disarm, Israeli troops to withdraw and reconstruction to begin, effectively stalled soon after taking effect. In July, Hamas agreed to a Board of Peace roadmap to surrender its weapons and hand governance of Gaza to a civilian transitional authority, but Israel rejected it.
“Every day that Israel continues strikes against Hamas targets, it delays putting Hamas' agreement to the roadmap to the test.” Board of Peace
On the same day the report emerged, Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz said Israel would not withdraw from Gaza until Hamas was dismantled and the territory demilitarised.
Another winter in tents and rubble
More than 2 million Palestinians now live crammed into around a third of Gaza, mostly in makeshift tents and damaged buildings, under the control of Hamas fighters. The other two-thirds, occupied by Israel, have been largely razed and depopulated.
Last week, heavy rain flooded displacement camps across Gaza, and more is expected later this month. For families who have lost their homes, every downpour is a new test of survival.
Divided reactions
Senior Hamas official Basem Naim dismissed the report as “pure disinformation,” accusing the Board of Peace of giving Israel cover to evade its obligations under the plan and continue its aggression in Gaza. The office of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Trump's plan has received strong international backing, though the Board of Peace itself has met with scepticism from many of Washington's Western allies. Meanwhile, Netanyahu's right-wing coalition remains in power in a caretaker capacity after losing its majority in an inconclusive election last month.
















