MAIN ARTICLE
How the court reached its sentence
The court’s published explanation makes the case more complex than a simple tally of guilty and not-guilty charges. Au originally faced three subversion charges, three charges of establishing contact with overseas individuals or groups for activities endangering national security, and one secrecy charge. The judges eventually imposed separate punishments for four offences: one subversion count, two overseas-contact counts and the secrecy breach. Another overlapping contact offence was not separately punished because the court considered it covered by the more serious subversion offence arising from the same conduct.
The individual terms were 11 years and three months for subversion, three years and nine months on each of two external-contact counts, and nine months for disclosure of confidential information. Applying Macau’s combined-sentence rules, the court fixed a single 12½-year prison term rather than simply adding the penalties together. It also acquitted Au of two further subversion counts, finding insufficient proof that the alleged conduct reached the specific legal threshold for that crime. Those distinctions matter: the assessment of an act, the evidence supporting it and the final classification of an offence are separate questions.

















