Two Jews Three Opinions and a Tense Time in Family Group Chats
According to CNN and The New York Times, the 2025 mayoral election with candidate Zohran Mamdani, a 34-year-old democratic socialist, has exposed the rift. Mamdani, who started a Students for Justice in Palestine chapter in college, supports Boycott, Divest and Sanctions movement, called its conduct in Gaza a genocide and declined to say Israel has the right to exist as a Jewish state, has won Democratic primary but split Jewish voters.
Polls from Fox News and Marist both had 55 percent of Jewish likely voters backing former Governor Andrew Cuomo, running independent after losing to Mamdani in June primary. Mamdani had 32 percent with Jewish voters. Norman Needleman, 77, waiting in line on Upper West Side, said if I try and bend that far, I will break, quoting Fiddler on the Roof.
Phylisa Wisdom, director of New York Jewish Agenda, said folks have been really trying to reckon with how much does it matter that they have a mayor that has their same feelings about Israel. There are some who feel it is not most important thing when voting for mayor, and some who think it is existential. Cydney Schwartz, 33, liberal Democrat who lived in Israel, told CNN I hate my choices, she feels powerful connection to country but does not agree with Israel's politics or Netanyahu.
From Grand Central to Statue of Liberty and the Genocide Debate
The divide is not only at ballot box but in streets. According to Al Jazeera and Manila Standard, hundreds of mostly Jewish New Yorkers took over main hall of Grand Central Station to protest Israel's bombardment of Gaza, with police saying at least 200 arrested, organizers saying more than 300.
In another action, hundreds of Jewish activists peacefully occupied Statue of Liberty pedestal demanding end to what they called genocidal bombardment of civilians in Gaza, wearing black T-shirts saying Jews demand ceasefire now.
Friday evening hundreds gathered in Brooklyn with banner Jews Say Stop Genocide Against Palestinians. Audrey Sasson, who runs Jews for Racial and Economic Justice, said she has found refuge in leftist Jewish community and been heartened by seeing more Jews speaking out against what she calls a genocide in Gaza.
On other side, Philip Wolf, 25, told AFP he did not grow up religious, but having had family wiped out in the Holocaust, I know critical importance of continued flourishing Jewish state. Shared grief after Hamas attacks October 7, 2023 that left more than 1,300 Israelis dead has bolstered advocacy for Israel for some. Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove of Park Avenue Synagogue told congregation October 18 I believe Zohran Mamdani poses a danger to security of New York Jewish community, with more than 1,100 rabbis signing open letter agreeing.
Jewish Voter Resource Center poll May 31, 2026 found nearly half of American Jews under 35 say conflict should be solved by creating single country in Israel, West Bank and Gaza.
Younger Jews, Holidays and Identity Beyond Israel
According to AP-NORC poll June 2026, support for Israel is key component of religious identity for many Jewish adults ages 45 and older, but younger Jewish adults are more likely to prioritize other forms, like celebrating Jewish holidays. That suggests generational divide extends beyond politics to identity.
Survey of 1,022 Jewish adults including people who identify as Jewish by religion and religiously unaffiliated who identify as Jewish through culture found only about half of religious adults say Israel's ongoing military operations in Gaza are justified. Number drops to 2 in 10 among Jewish adults without affiliation.
Poll found 38 percent of Jewish respondents said US was too supportive of Israelis, while 28 percent said Israelis not supported enough, and 43 percent said US not supportive enough of Palestinians. These numbers reflect complexity of community where identity is defined not only by support for Israel but also by holidays, culture and justice, allowing space for both love of Israel and hard questions about its policies.

















