A green star quietly fades
Chef David Toutain witnessed the birth of the Green Star in 2020: his eponymous restaurant in Paris was among the first to receive it, and Feuille, his Hong Kong outpost, won one within a year of opening in 2023. Yet even after the award was retired, he still did not understand how it was assessed.
*“I have no idea. I don’t know the rules.” — David Toutain*
Michelin never made its inspectors’ criteria public. When announcing the Green Star’s phase-out, it said only that the award was “limited to gastronomy” and referred to an unspecified strategic pivot, leaving a lingering question: what does it really mean for a restaurant to be “sustainable”?
Why Michelin retreated
Before blaming Michelin, consider the context. Amid cooling ESG enthusiasm, the EU’s Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive took effect on September 27, requiring sustainability labels to be independently verified and open to all companies – a standard the Green Star’s self-reported process could never meet. In that climate, an unverifiable green badge became a liability rather than an asset.
Moreover, certifying sustainability in dining differs sharply from awarding stars for food: it requires examining energy use, waste systems, labour practices and supply chains extending far beyond the kitchen. Michelin’s inspectors were restaurant critics, not environmental assessors.







