MAIN STORY
A procedural decision, not a verdict
The Supreme Court’s public docket for case 26-13 records the denial on October 19. Justice Brett Kavanaugh did not participate in consideration of that petition. The justices provided no detailed explanation, which is customary when they decline review. Their order does not decide whether the three men committed the alleged offenses; it leaves the lower federal appeals court’s ruling in place.
Prosecutors accuse Khalid Sheikh Mohammed of directing the plot to hijack passenger aircraft and attack the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. The two other defendants seeking restoration of the agreements are Mustafa al Hawsawi and Walid bin 'Atash. Their cases are proceeding through the military commission system at Guantanamo, where lawyers have spent years contesting evidence, procedure and the scope of judicial authority.
How the 2024 agreements unraveled
In July 2024, the Pentagon official overseeing the military commissions accepted agreements negotiated with prosecutors and the defense. Under their terms, guilty pleas would have meant that prosecutors would not seek execution.
















