Collective power with two faces

K-pop fans have shown their power in admirable ways. They raised around $100,000 in Indonesia for people affected by earthquakes and floods; BTS fans raised $1 million for Black Lives Matter to match the group's own donation; and Kpop4Planet pressured companies to act on climate.

Yet the same organising capacity can turn into collective online attacks. When defending an idol means attacking someone else, the consequences can be grave.

When defending idols becomes attacking others

Stories from fan communities show how harsh online bullying can be:

  • The Japanese Enhyphen fan faced attacks, threats and attempts to dox her after trying to catch a member's attention at a US concert, despite apologising.
  • A long-time BTS fan was hit with a pile-on of rude comments simply for saying she disliked a new release, leading her to leave fan forums.
  • Fans of colour have been called racial slurs and doxed for calling out cultural appropriation in K-pop.

The fight between Illit and NewJeans fans over plagiarism claims, alongside a legal dispute between labels under Hybe, even dragged Le Sserafim into the fray simply because it shares the same parent company.