The preschool programme and its equality requirement
Since 2023, Colorado children have been eligible for 15 hours a week of publicly funded preschool before kindergarten. Participating schools can be public or private, secular or religious, but must give all children “equal opportunity” to enrol, regardless of the sexual orientation or gender identity of students or parents.
The Archdiocese of Denver oversees 34 Catholic preschools. Its policy is to admit only students from families who support Catholic beliefs, including on same-sex relationships and gender identity.
The two sides' arguments
The Catholic groups, represented by the conservative Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, argue the anti-discrimination mandate burdens their religious exercise. A core disagreement is whether Colorado discriminated against the Catholic preschools by refusing them an exemption while allowing schools to prioritise low-income and disabled children.
















