Four in the afternoon on a residential street
According to CBS News, the shooting took place at about 4 p.m. local time on Thursday, October 8, near the junction of West 225th Street and Marble Hill Avenue, as people were coming home from work and children were leaving school. The New York police commissioner, Jessica Tisch, said police cameras recorded a car backing into a parking spot, two men in plain clothes approaching, one with his gun drawn, and then the car moving out of frame.
Tisch said one ICE agent fired seven rounds at the car. Belgal was handcuffed, given first aid by city police and taken to hospital. The five-year-old boy was not injured and is being cared for by a relative. She stressed that the New York police took no part in the federal operation and were not present when the shots were fired.
The federal account
At a press conference on October 9, federal officials gave their version. According to The Independent, the main points are:
- The ICE official Marcos Charles said Belgal refused orders to get out of the car, accelerated into two government vehicles and then drove towards other agents.
- The Department of Homeland Security describes him as a Dominican national living in the country illegally, with a conviction for larceny and several arrests; Charles claims he has ties to the Trinitarios gang.














