MAIN TEXT
What the trace on the handle establishes
Government chemist Wai Wing-kong testified that DNA recovered from the hammer handle matched Alex Kwong. He gave a probability of approximately one in 6.2 billion that the relevant genetic combination would occur in another randomly selected person. Material on the hammer head was insufficient for analysis. Those findings concern different parts of the object and should not be compressed into a claim that every sample produced the same conclusion.
The one-in-6.2-billion figure is not the probability that the defendant is innocent. It concerns the rarity of the genetic characteristics in the comparison described to the court. A NIST scientific review distinguishes questions about DNA's source from questions about the activity that deposited it. Criminal responsibility requires assessment of the wider case. The statistic matters, but its meaning must remain attached to the question it actually addresses.
Testing explanations through cross-examination
Alex Kwong's lawyer, Andrew Raffell, suggested that DNA could have reached the handle for an innocent reason, such as sweat. Wai considered that unlikely unless a substantial amount of sweat had contacted the surface. This was an exchange between a proposed explanation and an expert assessment, rather than a final judicial finding about how the hammer was used. Reporting needs to preserve that distinction and the qualifications within the testimony.














