From disruptor to establishment
Once the industry’s great disruptor, Nike has become the establishment and is in the midst of a tricky turnaround aimed at holding on to its dominance. Missteps have sent its share price down about 75% over five years, from a peak of about $178 in November 2021 to around $35.50 in late September 2026.
According to veteran analyst Matt Powell, Nike made “several strategic errors” that have been hard to reverse, such as cutting ties with retailers to sell only directly online, and making limited-edition shoes too widely available. He also notes that the company spent research and development money on digital operations rather than new products.
The John Donahoe era and the digital pivot
The criticism is aimed at John Donahoe, the former eBay boss behind the direct-to-consumer online sales pivot. His four years in charge coincided with the share price plunge. Sales initially soared as pandemic restrictions boosted online shopping, but cost-of-living pressures later curbed consumer spending.
“They really shut down their innovation on product. Someone jokingly said they were trying to turn Nike into eBay.” — Matt Powell
As demand weakened in key markets such as China, Nike announced cost cuts and redundancies. Meanwhile, newer trend-savvy brands such as On and Hoka gradually took over shelf space once occupied by Nike.

















