MAIN CONTENT
A multiplier with more than one meaning
The dispute centers on a deceptively straightforward phrase. Anthropic promoted Claude Max as providing ‘5x or 20x more usage’ than its Pro offering. Plaintiffs Karl Kahn and Solomon Smith contend that someone paying a monthly subscription fee could reasonably understand that comparison as a monthly entitlement. Their lawsuit says the higher allowance in fact applies within five-hour sessions, while weekly ceilings limit how much work subscribers can complete over longer periods.
The court cited allegations that, for one Claude model, weekly usage was closer to 3.5 times Pro for Max 5x and six times Pro for Max 20x. Those ratios are allegations considered at the dismissal stage, not judicial measurements of every subscriber’s experience. Nonetheless, the distinction illustrates how an apparently simple marketing number can become ambiguous when access depends on both short and long usage windows.
What the judge allowed and rejected
Judge Alex Tse ruled that Smith’s consumer-protection claim under California’s Consumers Legal Remedies Act could continue, alongside claims for negligent misrepresentation and breach of contract. He dismissed Kahn’s claim under that consumer statute for insufficient allegations about personal rather than business use.















