The moment that decided the derby
In the sixtieth minute, Manchester City were already reduced to ten men after Phil Foden had been sent off earlier in the match. Josko Gvardiol crossed from the left flank into the penalty box, and Erling Haaland arrived at the back post to finish from close range past the Manchester United goalkeeper. The on field assistant referee immediately raised his flag for offside, and play stopped as the goal was initially disallowed. Within seconds, however, video referee Matt Donohue asked for the footage to be frozen for review, and the final call overturned the on field decision, awarding the goal to City. The goal ultimately handed Manchester City all three points and derby bragging rights, but it also left a lasting stain on the fairness of the contest.
It was hard to understand.
A shortened process and its cost
Post match analysis suggested the gravest error lay not in speed itself but in how narrowly the review was conducted. The VAR team focused almost entirely on whether Haaland himself was offside, using semi automated technology to clear him, when it should also have examined the entire phase of play, from Gvardiol's cross through the position and influence of Enzo Fernandez, who was standing offside and diving to reach the ball ahead of Haaland.

















