Three hours in Nahalin
Lander, a former New York City comptroller and mayoral candidate who is running in the November 3 midterm elections, had been in the West Bank since Monday with the Protect the Harvest coalition. He said he had picked olives on the two previous days without incident. On Wednesday, according to the Israeli group Rabbis for Human Rights and the North American Jewish organisation T’ruah, soldiers and police arrived about two hours after the harvest began and told the group they were in a closed military zone.
“We did not present a security risk to anyone. We did nothing more provocative than harvest olives.” — Brad Lander
Lander, who is Jewish, said he was released with a warning, apparently because of his public profile, while the others were held for about nine hours. Speaking to reporters from Beit Jala, he said he had seen with his own eyes how difficult it is for Palestinian farmers to reach their groves, use their roads and stay on their land.
Two accounts of one harvest
Israeli authorities describe the events differently. The military said harvesting near Beitar Illit requires prior coordination, which had not taken place, and that an uncoordinated harvest close to an Israeli community posed a security risk; it did not say harvesting there was forbidden. Police said the group had been gathering olives near the settlement fence, which was prohibited, and that Lander needed authorisation and was aware of the requirement. Israel’s foreign ministry accused him of looking for a confrontation, called the visit a stunt and said he had ignored advice to coordinate with Israeli authorities.

















