A Ruling in BYD’s Favor
According to the ruling published by the District Court of The Hague on Thursday, Judge H.F.R. van Heemstra ordered JLR to destroy materials obtained in a raid on BYD’s Netherlands offices within 24 hours. According to the South China Morning Post, JLR faces a fine of €500,000, about US$553,100, if it fails to comply; some other reports describe the penalty as accruing per hour of delay.
The preliminary ruling overturns the evidence-gathering raid. BYD’s lawyers had challenged the scope of the seizure, calling it a “fishing expedition.” No finding of intellectual property infringement against BYD has been made.
Allegations of Copying the Defender
The dispute centers on BYD’s Ti7 SUV, which has drawn many comparisons with the Land Rover Defender:
- JLR accuses BYD of copyright infringement and “slavish imitation” of the Defender and suspects BYD reverse-engineered some technology for the Ti7.
- In August 2026, court-appointed bailiffs raided BYD’s offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp and seized digital records.
- JLR chose the Dutch courts for their strict intellectual property enforcement; lawyers for both sides argued in court in October over how the seized records could be used.













