An alarming error rate
The Home Office began using the Asylum Case Summarisation (ACS) tool in April to summarise transcripts of interviews with asylum seekers. According to data obtained by the Open Rights Group, 259 expert checks were carried out between April and the end of July: 203 summaries were reviewed once and 56 a second time.
Of the 203 primary reviews, 45, or 22%, failed accuracy standards and 19 were flagged for further review. Of the 56 secondary reviews, 30, or 54%, were deemed sub-standard. A summary fails if it contains multiple factual errors or misrepresentations, is largely inconsistent with what the asylum seeker said, or is not useful to the caseworker.
“This data shows that human oversight of the Asylum Case Summarisation (ACS) tool is worryingly limited and inaccuracy far too common in the few cases where its results have been checked.” — Bell Ribeiro-Addy
Speed at the cost of accuracy?
The Labour government has sharply reduced the number of people awaiting an initial asylum decision, to 40,168 in June, down 56% on 2025. But the appeals backlog has grown 50% to 90,741 cases.

















