A court that chose to stand aside
In a decision published on Tuesday, November 10, Supreme Court President Isaac Amit, Deputy President Noam Sohlberg and Justice Daphne Barak-Erez wrote that ACRI’s petition had been exhausted. The justices nonetheless left open the possibility that they might need to address the matter again in the future.
The justices cited the state’s announcement that the Prison Service is prepared to allow personal meetings between ICRC representatives and prisoners, and that the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is also ready to hold such meetings in the detention facilities it runs.
Yet according to information obtained by the newspaper Haaretz, not a single visit has taken place since the June ruling. The ICRC is struggling to reach an agreement with the state in the face of a series of severe conditions.
The June ruling and a reminder about the rule of law
On June 3, 2026, Israel’s High Court unanimously accepted ACRI’s petition, finding that the government’s decision to bar the ICRC from visiting security prisoners had no basis in Israeli or international law and therefore had to be annulled. The justices acknowledged that the case raised a difficult question about a state’s obligations toward its own enemies.















