Three small bets, a big payout
A Kalshi spokesperson confirmed the probe to The Wall Street Journal but declined to comment further. Trades on Kalshi are anonymous to the public, but the company keeps records of its traders' identities.
What makes the bets notable is not their size but their timing and odds. With only about $173 at stake in total, the bettors stand to collect around $9,600, more than 50 times their outlay.
A suspicious timeline
According to a Wall Street Journal analysis of publicly available Kalshi data, the bets were placed in this sequence:
- A $19 bet was placed around 10:42 p.m. ET on Thursday and is slated to pay out $1,896.
- Two bets of about $74 and $80 were placed around 1:41 p.m. on Friday and are expected to pay out $3,689 and $4,023.
- The New York Times and other outlets began reporting the pick around 2 p.m. ET the same day.
In the days before the news broke, Kalshi traders gave Zacharia only about a 1 per cent chance of being appointed. The gap between such long odds and an accurate outcome is what drew attention to the trades.














