A call for prosecution
According to AP, responding to reporters' questions about the New York Times report before boarding Air Force One, Trump said both Peltola and Dan J. Sullivan should be prosecuted. Earlier, on social media, he wrote that Peltola should suffer the “legal and political consequences” for what she has done, accusing her of voter fraud.
“I think they should be prosecuted.” — Donald Trump
It is a fresh escalation after the Justice Department, at Trump's direction, filed suit seeking to delay certification if Peltola defeats Senator Sullivan and the votes for Dan J. Sullivan are enough to change the outcome. So far, no criminal charges have been brought in the matter.
Senator Sullivan demands she “come clean”
Appearing on Fox News on the evening of October 28, Senator Dan S. Sullivan, who is seeking a third term, urged Peltola to be straight with voters. He advised Alaskans to question his opponent directly.
“Look Mary Peltola in the eye and ask her, ‘Did you cheat?’” — Dan S. Sullivan
According to The New York Times, the newspaper obtained text messages among members of Peltola's campaign discussing finding people who share the senator's name. Dan J. Sullivan went on to make it through the open primary in August and is one of four candidates on the ranked-choice ballot.
The accused respond
Peltola's campaign denies recruiting any candidates. When the Justice Department filed its lawsuit, her spokesperson called it “a despicable political threat to overturn an election,” according to KTUU.
For his part, Dan J. Sullivan has long maintained that he did not run at Democrats' behest, and in June said he had no contact with the Peltola campaign.
“Zero, none, zilch.” — Dan J. Sullivan
In September, according to the Alaska Beacon, when Trump hinted at a possible investigation, Dan J. Sullivan wrote that he would not let threats of retribution force him out of the race. He did not respond to AP's request for comment on October 28.
The numbers and the ranked ballot
Alaska uses an open primary that sends four candidates to a general election decided by ranked-choice voting. The results of the August primary, according to the Alaska Beacon, showed:
- Mary Peltola led with 49.5% of the vote.
- Senator Dan S. Sullivan received 41.4%.
- Dan J. Sullivan received about 2.5%.
- Gerald Heikes became the fourth candidate after another Democrat withdrew.
Trump has argued that 2.5% is significant in a close race. Alaska's state officials, by contrast, say they have taken steps to clearly distinguish the two candidates on the ballot, and in June the state Supreme Court ruled there was no basis for removing Dan J. Sullivan.
The line between politics and the law
According to The New York Times, adding candidates to the ballot to split an opponent's vote is common and generally considered legal, and both parties have used the tactic in Alaska. Trump's supporters argue that if the allegations are proven, it amounts to deceiving voters and should be punished; critics worry about a president publicly calling for the prosecution of his party's political opponent on the eve of an election.
Whatever the outcome on November 3, the episode has raised major questions about campaign ethics, the role of law enforcement and voters' trust in the ballot, questions that may linger long after the votes are counted.
















