The Vanessa Emde Case
Vanessa “Vedi” Emde, born in 1981 in Düsseldorf and a resident of the Neukölln district for more than 15 years, was elected to Berlin’s House of Representatives on September 20 as a Left Party candidate. She has become a focus of controversy over statements criticizing Israel that many inside and outside the party consider to have crossed a line. The Berlin Left leadership, headed by Kerstin Wolter, demanded that she give up her seat, saying trust had been lost, but Emde rejected the demand. The party’s parliamentary group is weighing further steps as Berlin moves toward a red-green-red governing coalition.
In his commentary, Martin Niewendick argues that the party should think very carefully about whom it turns into an opponent by pushing out a popular figure like Emde, and treats the Wagenknecht case as a warning to all sides about the danger of fragmentation.
Lessons From Sahra Wagenknecht
The author recalls the path of Sahra Wagenknecht, an icon of the German left:
- In the 2010s, she was seen as the figure who kept the Left Party on life support, often signing autographs for hours after speeches in town squares.
- From August 2018, she launched the “Aufstehen” movement, billed as a left-wing rallying movement, which failed due to vagueness, overly rapid growth and her personal leadership style.














