MAIN CONTENT

The 10.6% headline is dramatic, but incomplete

Destatis said real new manufacturing orders, adjusted for seasonal and calendar effects, fell 10.6% in August from July. That was far worse than the roughly 1% decline expected in a Reuters poll. But the statistics office stressed that the drop was almost entirely caused by “other transport equipment,” where orders fell 61.5% after jumping a revised 129.4% in July because of unusually large contracts for ships, railway rolling stock and aircraft.

That illustrates how monthly manufacturing data can be distorted by a handful of multibillion-euro contracts. When large-scale orders are removed, total new orders fell just 0.1%. In other words, underlying demand was broadly flat in August rather than collapsing at a double-digit pace.

Domestic demand looks weaker than foreign demand

The geographic breakdown still provides a reason for caution. Domestic orders fell 17.3% from the previous month, much more than the 5.4% decline in foreign orders.