A scathing ruling from a Los Angeles court
According to Reuters, Judge Carter, an appointee of former President Bill Clinton, issued his decision a day after a lengthy hearing in federal court in Los Angeles. He wrote that never before in American history had the federal government, on the eve of an election, sought to coerce state and local governments to abandon their constitutional election procedures and bend to the will of the executive branch. In his view, the request ran afoul of longstanding principles giving states control over their elections.
“Eroded trust in our democracy is irreparable.” — David Carter
According to Democracy Docket, the judge also concluded that the Justice Department likely lacks standing and an appropriate cause of action, and that the requested remedy could violate several federal voting laws. According to NBC News, he pressed the government's lawyer at the hearing: “Where is the evidence?”
The arguments on both sides
The lawsuit, filed by the Justice Department on October 15 against California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County election officials, turns on several key points of dispute:
- The Justice Department says it compiled a list of more than 20,000 “likely noncitizens” based on a purchased voter list matched against government data, according to CNN.
- The administration argues the matter is urgent because once ballots are separated from their envelopes for confidentiality, ineligible ballots can no longer be retrieved.
- California calls the data “suspect,” says its safeguards are robust and argues that setting ballots aside would disenfranchise eligible voters.
- According to CBS News, Los Angeles County said only just over 7,000 people on the list had addresses in the county, while NPR reported that some people on the list appear to be U.S.-born.
Judge Carter said that if the government believes noncitizens voted, it can prosecute them, since ballot envelopes contain identifying information. Indeed, according to NPR, the Justice Department has already charged 28 people in California with voting-related crimes.
The Justice Department appeals
That same evening, the Justice Department filed an appeal with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Earlier, that court had rejected an “unusual” emergency request by the department in a 2–1 decision, saying an appeal before the lower court had ruled was premature. Justice Department lawyer Bill Essayli sharply criticized the ruling.
“This ongoing emergency disenfranchises American citizens through dilution.” — Bill Essayli
According to CBS News, the administration plans to seek an emergency order from the Supreme Court if necessary. Meanwhile, more than 3.7 million people in California have already voted and over 500,000 ballots have been counted, according to KTNV.
Not just California
The Trump administration has also sought to intervene in elections in two states with competitive races. In Alaska, the Justice Department asked a court to prevent certification of results if the Republican incumbent senator loses by a slim margin, arguing that another candidate with a similar name on the ballot could confuse voters. Alaska has asked for the case to be dismissed, saying it has taken steps to distinguish the two candidates.
In Washington state, the Justice Department sent a letter asking officials not to count ballots from 400 voters it said may not be citizens. The state's top elections official said the timing of the request suggested it was intended to cast unfounded suspicion on the results. Voting rights activists also worry that the federal government's screening methods could wrongly flag naturalized citizens.
A legal battle on the eve of the midterms
California is the most populous U.S. state and a Democratic stronghold, with 52 seats in the House of Representatives, more than any other state. Trump has repeatedly insisted that states are not doing enough to stop noncitizens from voting, which he says is widespread, while multiple studies and state audits show it is rare. Supporters of the administration stress that even a small number of illegal ballots could tip close races.
According to CNN, election law experts view the California case as a test of how far the Justice Department might go to disrupt or dispute a state's ballot-counting process. Whatever the final outcome, the confrontation shows that courtrooms could become a key front in the 2026 midterm elections.

















