ARTICLE
Two accounts meet outside a cinema
One side of the plaza carried Israeli and American flags; the other led into the screening of NAZA. The Times of Israel reported several dozen participants at the rally organized by the Israeli-American Council outside Lincoln Center. Placards and mobile screens recalled Hamas’s October 2023 attack on Israel and those taken hostage. These were people insisting that their own painful history be seen, rather than merely an abstract objection to a film.
Rom El-Hai and Shalev Bitton, survivors of the massacre at the Nova music festival, joined Yunis Alkarnawi, a Bedouin Israeli who helped rescue people there. Their presence helps explain why demonstrators wanted audiences to keep October 7 in view. In its call for the gathering, the organizing group said it would challenge the film’s narrative and guard against that day being erased from the story.
The screening went ahead as part of the New York Film Festival. Protesters may challenge a work outside a theater, while filmmakers and audiences may bring testimony into public view. The supplied report gives no indication that the rally prevented the film from being shown. More revealing is the way each side asked others to acknowledge human loss, even as they focused on different moments in the same conflict.

















