A complaint that read like a machine
Judge Lanham described the filing as an improper shotgun pleading, a term courts use for complaints that pile up facts without clearly linking them to specific legal claims, making it difficult for defendants to respond and for judges to rule. She said the voluminous allegations were repetitive and did not appear necessary.
George's lawsuit, filed in September, alleges that the Agriculture Department illegally retaliated against her and subjected her to a hostile work environment. The dismissal does not decide whether those allegations are true; it gives her the chance to present them again in a clearer form.
An unusual order
Judges commonly dismiss poorly drafted complaints with permission to amend, but explicitly barring a litigant from using AI to prepare the next version is rare. The court wants the amended complaint to reflect the plaintiff's own account of what happened and which claims she intends to pursue.
“George must personally draft the allegations she believes relevant to her claims.” — Krissa Lanham
For the remainder of the case, AI is not prohibited, but both parties must disclose any use and certify that AI-generated content has been checked. The Agriculture Department and the judge did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The plaintiff's view
George told Reuters that she found no law limiting the number of pages in a court filing. She acknowledged that AI was partially used but said that if the language is valid, she does not understand why the case was dismissed. She plans to amend her complaint and refile.
Her reaction reflects a dilemma for many people who cannot afford a lawyer. AI tools promise to help self-represented litigants organise their thoughts and use legal terminology, yet they can also produce long, unfocused or inaccurate documents that make it harder for courts to understand a genuine grievance.
Courts tighten the rules
Lawyers and litigants are generally allowed to use AI for research and drafting as long as they verify the results. But judges across the United States are increasingly sanctioning filings that contain invented case citations, errors or incoherent arguments. In Florida, an appeals court is weighing sanctions against a lawyer over what it called AI-generated slop, filings it described as excessively long and sometimes gibberish; the lawyer denies breaking court rules.
Some judges now require parties to disclose AI use, while others have banned it outright in preparing filings. Supporters of firm rules say they protect the integrity of the courts; critics warn that blanket bans may punish those who rely on technology to access a complex legal system without professional help.
















