MAIN STORY
From privacy promises to an extraordinary judgment
Jurors concluded that Meta made 26 misleading statements concerning privacy and related matters. New Mexico’s Department of Justice said they found 43,899,725 violations of state law. This count reflects the legal treatment of statements reaching a large potential audience; it should not be mistaken for a count of distinct individuals who were individually proved to have suffered harm.
In his October 21 order, Judge Francis Mathew considered a statutory calculation above $219 billion and set civil penalties at $25 billion. Even after that reduction, the amount ranks among the largest corporate penalties imposed in the United States. But entry of judgment is not the same as collection: appellate review and challenges to proportionality may continue for years.
The decision also exposes an uncomfortable truth about account settings and privacy policies. Statements about who can access information and what control users possess are not mere marketing flourishes. In consumer law, they can become evidence against a business if their substance proves misleading.














