MAIN CONTENT
A plea to nine justices
Khalil’s lawyers asked the Supreme Court to make clear that immigration law does not prevent noncitizens from pursuing cases arguing they were detained to punish constitutionally protected speech. While the Supreme Court decides, a lower-court order barring his re-detention remains in place.
*“If the Trump administration can punish someone for pro-Palestine speech, this or any future administration can punish anyone for any speech.” — Mahmoud Khalil*
If the 3rd Circuit ruling stands, Khalil could be arrested and deported, since in April the Board of Immigration Appeals rejected his challenge to an immigration judge’s order that he be removed to Algeria or Syria. A separate appeal of that removal order remains pending before the 5th Circuit.
Two views of the same case
The Trump administration treats Khalil’s case as a matter of immigration enforcement. Secretary of State Marco Rubio invoked a rarely used provision of the Immigration and Nationality Act to deem Khalil removable, citing his involvement in what the government described as “antisemitic” and disruptive protests at Columbia in 2024 that fostered a hostile environment for Jewish students.

















