A haunting apology

At the final whistle at the Sinigaglia, Carrick shook hands with Cesc Fabregas and then marched over to the few dozen United fans who had stayed through the rain, raising his hands in apology. It recalled Ole Gunnar Solskjaer after a defeat by the same score at Watford in November 2021, a gesture later seen as a farewell. Now it is impossible not to wonder whether Carrick is waving goodbye too.

The lifeless performance, followed by Fernandes telling TNT Sports that the passive display stemmed from the coaching staff's instruction not to press man-to-man but to sit off, has turned concern into full-blown crisis. It was the second week in a row a United player had spoken out against those above, after Lisandro Martinez criticised summer recruitment under technical director Jason Wilcox following the 2-0 defeat in Madrid.

Questions of fitness and spirit

Responding to Fernandes, Carrick said the team had half-pressed man-to-man in the second half and conceded from it, and stressed that whatever the system, a team that does not run forwards and back will not win. He has previously dismissed statistics showing United near the bottom for running output, but this time he raised the issue himself.

Advertisement300 × 250

The key question is whether that lack of running stems from tactics, from fitness work in pre-season, from the physical limitations of players recruited, or from disillusionment with the club's environment and ambitions. It may well be a combination of all of them.

Problems from the top

In the writer's view, even a new head coach would face the same issues, because they stem from the top, where the Glazer family have run United from across the Atlantic for 21 years. Sir Jim Ratcliffe also bears heavy responsibility, with a hands-on management style that reaches deep into Carrington. He appointed Omar Berrada as chief executive, who brought in Jason Wilcox, formerly Manchester City's academy director and Southampton's sporting director, as the top football executive. Dan Ashworth, recruited at significant cost, was dismissed after six months.

Results have declined since INEOS invested, with the exception of Carrick's interim spell last season. If Carrick goes, it would be the third mid-season managerial change in three years, after Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim. Ten Hag has also spoken recently about a toxic culture he felt went unchecked by the current leadership.

Signs of a dressing-room rift

Fernandes was substituted in the 67th minute, and his decision to blame the coaching staff was a clear act of insubordination. Matheus Cunha, who exchanged words with Carrick in the first half, was taken off at the break. The treatment room is full again, with eight players out through injury or illness. Having produced the Premier League's best record over 17 games with 39 points, Carrick has now won only two of his last 11, against Ipswich Town and Azerbaijan's FC Sabah.

The final humiliation came from Fabregas, who said he regretted telling his players to stop running to save energy, which allowed Joshua Zirkzee to score in stoppage time. For Carrick, part of a United side that once ruled Europe with intensity under Sir Alex Ferguson, that must have hurt. Asked whether the players were still playing for him, Carrick insisted he gives everything for the club.

It's not about playing for me, it's about playing for this football club.

- Michael Carrick

Subscribe to the QMVN newsletter