A gap of nearly $37 billion
At a hearing on October 1 in the state capital, Santa Fe, lawyers for New Mexico asked Judge Francis Mathew to impose a penalty of $35 billion to $40 billion on Meta. Under the state’s consumer protection law, each violation can draw a fine of up to $5,000. Multiplied by the more than 43 million violations the jury identified, the theoretical maximum exceeds $215 billion.
Randi McGinn, a lawyer representing the state, acknowledged that applying the full amount would breach the due process limits of the U.S. Constitution. The state is therefore seeking about 20% of the possible total, an amount large enough to move the company’s share price while still respecting its constitutional rights. In her view, only one thing makes a corporation of Meta’s size truly listen.
“This court should speak to Meta in the only language it understands, which is money and its stock value.” — Randi McGinn
The numbers behind the verdict
The trial lasted two weeks, opening on September 8 and closing with a verdict on September 25. What the jury found can be summed up in a few figures:

















