Why Refusal: Biometrics and Exceptional Criteria
According to Arab News and The Guardian, Home Office guidance requires evidence that a person faces a personal risk of harm which is separate to the level of risk faced by the wider population. The two families say they lack food and medical supplies and have been displaced multiple times. They requested decisions before submitting biometric data due to challenges in a war zone.
The nearest reliable centre is in Cairo. The Home Office refused, saying their situations were not compelling as to make them exceptional or different to other people in Gaza. Judge Jackson said we do not consider that in the context of the conflict in Gaza that it is necessary for a person to show that they are specifically targeted to be able to establish that they are at risk.
The judgment found guidance breaches Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Cecilia Correale, solicitor at Islington Law Centre with the Migrants' Law Project at Asylum Aid, told The Guardian this is an important judgment with wider consequences.
Ukraine Precedent and a Family of Six in a Tent
The case highlights disparity. According to The National and OpenDemocracy, more than 25,000 people signed a petition asking government to waive fees and salary thresholds for Palestinians displaced by attacks on Gaza.

















