MAIN ARTICLE
A warning from a symposium in Manhattan
Speaking at Touro University on November 16, Menin recalled protests around the third anniversary of the Hamas-led attacks on Israel. According to reporting by The Times of Israel, she described seeing Hamas and Hezbollah flags and images of Yahya Sinwar outside City Hall. The publication also documented some such displays. Their presence, however, does not establish that every participant in the wider demonstrations supported those groups.
Menin, whose parents and grandparents survived the Holocaust, characterized the apparent celebration of US-designated terrorist organizations as profoundly disturbing. Her remarks focused on the harm such imagery can cause to Jewish residents who already fear harassment. The civic question extends further: how can public officials distinguish protected expression from specific threats while ensuring that criticism of political movements and governments remains possible?
Touro’s published program confirms that the symposium examined antisemitism in North American academic life, its scope, historical and legal perspectives, and training initiatives. Participants included scholars, lawyers and elected representatives. Menin joined a conversation with law professor Thane Rosenbaum. The gathering’s focus reflected its organizers’ mission and should not be mistaken for a complete spectrum of public views on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict.

















