MAIN ARTICLE
A court draws a line around editorial independence
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit affirmed District Judge Royce Lamberth’s August 2025 decision in favour of Abramowitz. Judges Sri Srinivasan, Cornelia Pillard and Florence Pan ruled unanimously. Rather than treating the case as an ordinary employment disagreement, the panel examined the legal architecture created to protect the news organisation’s management from direct political intervention. The court said the special process for removing the director is a substantive safeguard, not a formality that agency officials can bypass.
Under that framework, the International Broadcasting Advisory Board holds the relevant removal authority. The Trump administration had dismantled that body after returning to office, but its absence did not give Kari Lake replacement powers. As reported by The Washington Post and Bloomberg Law, the appellate court rejected the government’s constitutional challenge to the board’s role. The judges also reasoned that the president retains indirect authority because board members can be removed, while the VOA director enjoys a distinct statutory protection.

















